Jurisdictions

Only now I have stumbled upon Opinion 01/09 - Statement by the Advocates General of the Court of Justice of the European Union concerning the European Patent and the Community Patent Court as planned by the EU Council; see my earlier postings here, there and there. The date on that Document (Original in French only) is July 2, 2010; however, the Opinion was not published on the Official website of the Court of Justice of the European Union (formerly known as European Court of Justice, or ECJ for short). A link to the French version was posted on August 19, 2010, on EPLAW Patent Blog.

I won't understand those childish games played by interested circles inside of and close to the EU Council in a futile attempt to withhold such important documents from the eyes of the general public.

Anyway, what the Advocates General have to say to the proposal submitted by the EU Council last year is highly relevant:

A first snippet from the Document makes clear that the Advocates General are not opposed to the general layout of the proposed Patents Court (PC) to resolve certain classes of disputes between individuals:

"61. We should first examine whether the European Union judicial system, as resulting from the treaties, prohibits assigning to the future PC sole competence to hear certain disputes between individuals in the Community patent field.

62. The Advocates-General do not believe that that is the case."

The bombshell, however, appears a bit later in the Document: